Motif Duo vs. Spectra S9 Breast Pumps - Which Should You Buy? (2023)

  • One
  • Latest posts

Chrissy Bobic

After spending 10 years babysitting, Chrissy now dedicates herself to caring for her own son and trying to find the time between potty training and veggies in her food to binge watch. It's no better than a good poop story, either, because every parent has them.

Recent posts by Chrissy Bobic(See everything)

  • Baby Dry Diapers vs. Swaddlers: A Parent's Guide- 26. May 2022
  • The ultimate guide to the best cesarean scar creams- 20. May 2022
  • Solly sling vs. Moby: Which sling is better?- 20. May 2022

Whether you choose to breastfeed, pump exclusively, or a combination of both, at some point you will wonder about breast pumping. And since they're both dual wearable options, you might want to compare the Motif Duo and Spectra S9 breast pumps to see which one works best for you.

At first glance they look pretty similar and both even had similar sized battery interfaces that are small enough to hold in the palm of your hand or slip into your pocket while pumping.

The name of the game here is on the go or wherever you are and pumping bothbreast pumpsThey offer a similar discretion and ease of use. But you better believe that both have their differences, so choosing between them is a bit easier.

If cost is your main deciding factor, you might want to opt for the Motif Duo, which is slightly cheaper than the Spectra S9. Also, the Motif Duo weighs less than half a pound, while the Spectra S9 weighs 0.5 pounds.

Both are easy to take with you and toss in your purse or diaper bag, but some parents may prefer the lighter option. Both have rechargeable battery packs that each hold about the same charge, so you may need to look at other aspects of the pumps to decide which is best for you.

Both the Motif Duo and Spectra S9 offer ease of use wherever you go. The key things to consider are battery life, accessibility, and massage levels before making a final decision. Both pumps have their pros and cons and before deciding between them you might want to take a closer look.


  • Motif duo breast pump

    If you need a pump at work or on the go, the Motif Duo breast pump is definitely the best choice. Weighing less than half a pound and the battery fits in the palm of your hand, both are required for the perfect portable pump. But it offers even more.

    You can choose to use it as a single or double pump depending on your needs, and it has 10 different pumping and massage modes, allowing you to pump as much as you need each time. In total, it has three different configurations. There is one for expression, one for massage and one for memory.

    A fully charged battery will give you 2.5 hours of use, but the pump will automatically turn off after 30 minutes so you don't have to worry about turning it off after every pumping session. It also has a whisper-quiet motor so you can discreetly pump anywhere.

    The pump itself comes with multiple reservoirs and a power adapter for charging. It also comes with two milk storage bottles so you can pump right in every time.

    The closed piping system inside the pump helps prevent milk contamination and the backlit LCD display on the portable battery pack is easy to read. If you're looking for portability and customization to get the pumping experience that's right for you, then the Motif Duo breast pump might just be what you're looking for.


    • Available configurations:It features 10 massage levels and 10 expression settings, as well as built-in memory to track your favorite pumping habits.
    • Accesories:The pump comes with two bottles, two teats, milk collection containers and a power adapter.
    • Battery life:It has a battery life of 2.5 hours.
    • Where to buy:It's currently out of stock on Amazon, but you can also find it from your insurance provider.
    • Has this article been removed?:There are no recent or current recalls for this pump.


    • The pump is as light as you could hope for, yet strong enough to use multiple times per charge.
    • You can use them as a single or double breast pump.
    • There are numerous configurations to choose from to get the right strength and comfort for your pumping needs every time.
    • The memory feature can remember which settings work best for you so you don't have to.
    • It's so quiet you can use it unobtrusively almost anywhere.

    In contrast

    • Some mothers who wear Medela breast shields may be put off by the fact that this pump does not fit them well.
    • Unlike the Spectra S9 breast pump, it can be difficult to find a place to buy this particular pump.
    • Once the battery dies, the power seems to slow down and become less powerful.


    “The Motif Pump is great because it's so small I can throw it in my bag and I don't have to carry an extra bag and it's quiet! I was worried it wouldn't be strong enough given its size, but it's just as strong as my old pump!” –Katy Deckardat Amazon.

    “Small, quiet and best of all: light! Because I have enough takeaway stuff in the diaper bag. Very happy." -Meagan Lucasat Amazon.

    “I love this pump. I have the Babysteps home pump. And I take it with me on the go so I don't mess up my pump schedule. Small, super quiet and super suction power without a plug-in power supply.“ –Jennyat Amazon.

    Motif Duo vs. Spectra S9 Breast Pumps - Which Should You Buy? (5)

    Motif portable double electric breast pump


    Check the price

    We earn a commission when you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

    14.02.2023 05:27 |

    Sacaleches Spectra S9

    The Spectra brand is already known for their pumping options, so it's only natural that theBomba Spectra S9the perfect solution for being on the go. It's lightweight at just 0.5 pounds and small enough to fit in the palm of your hand.

    You can express at home, on the go or at work. The pump is so versatile. It also has a built-in rechargeable battery and 10 different suction levels. This will ensure you get the most out of every pumping session, no matter how many times you need to express per day. Like the Motif Duo, you can use the Spectra S9 as a single or dual pump, and it's discreet enough to wear to work or on the go.

    The pump includes wide mouth bottles, rings and caps for easy storage every time you pump. There are also non-return valves to prevent milk from entering the hose and bacteria from building up. The LCD screen is easy to read and the buttons are easy to use to get just the right amount of suction during your pumping sessions.

    You can also take comfort in the fact that the Spectra company is owned by mothers, nurses and lactation consultants. So not only are you getting a high-quality, useful pump, you're getting one from a company that knows what they're doing and what moms really need.


    • Available configurations:There are 10 different suction levels so you can choose which one is right for you based on your pumping session.
    • Accesories:The pump comes with wide-mouth bottles, rings and caps, a power adapter and 24mm funnels.
    • Battery life:It has a battery life of 2.5 hours on a full charge.
    • Where to buy:You can find it on the manufacturer's website and on Amazon.
    • Has this article been removed?:There are no recent or current recalls for this pump.


    • The battery has a long enough lifespan that you can use it several times on the go.
    • You can easily slip the breast pump into your purse or diaper bag so you can use it on the go or at work when needed.
    • After 30 minutes, the pump will stop automatically, which can make your work easier.
    • It's easy to read the LCD screen and operate the buttons to get the right setting every time.
    • There's even a timer that lets you know how long you've been pumping.

    In contrast

    • You have to manually switch from the massage to the expression setting as it doesn't switch automatically when the time comes.
    • There are many parts that need checking and cleaning, which can be a bit of a chore.
    • Pumping as much as they'd like might not help everyone, especially compared to the Spectra S2.


    “This is an effective wearable breast pump add-on if you regularly use a Spectra s1 or s2 at lower settings. I only pump with an S1 when I'm at home and bought the S9 to pump on the go at work. From the lowest settings (70/3 Massage and 54/3-5 Expression) on my S1, the settings available on the S9 worked equally well to empty both breasts in 20 minutes.” –tif kat Amazon.

    “I love this pump. I mean I hate pumps but the portability makes it better. Wearing it with one of those pump bras, I can slip it into a fanny pack and walk around the house, do chores, or work at my desk. I love that I don't have to plug it in except for charging. It's light, fairly strong, and quieter than some Medelas." –C. Mazurat Amazon.

    “I have this and the Spectra 2 pump and I love them both. I'm an exclusive pumper so having efficient pumps is important. This is great for being out and about getting things done around the house while you pump. I can usually get sessions from 4 to 25 minutes for free. It's louder than the Spectra 2, but it's not too distracting." –Sara Pat Amazon.

    Motif Duo vs. Spectra S9 Breast Pumps - Which Should You Buy? (7)

    Electric breast pump Spectra 9 Plus

    176,39 $

    Check the price

    We earn a commission when you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

    14.02.2023 10:32 |

    The judgment

    Although both pumps are good options for pumping milk on the go and in bulk when needed, the Spectra S9 breast pump is the best option in this case. It's more affordable, easier to find, and comes from a brand that's already highly trusted and popular. Not to mention the fact that it has 10 levels of suction, the one you will surely need to get the most out of every pumping session.

    The Motif Duo is on par with the Spectra S9 in terms of battery life and overall size, but it's a strong, hospital-grade pump that you can easily buy and use pretty much anywhere. That's not to say that opting for the Motif Duo is by no means a bad choice, but compared to the Spectra S9 breast pump, it's a stronger option overall.

    final thoughts

    Choosing the right breast pump is a big deal, no matter how insignificant it may seem compared to other baby needs.

    The right pump can mean the difference between uncomfortable pumping at work and having a discreet, comfortable pump that lets you get work done when you need it. In this case, the pump that makes the difference for you is the Spectra S9. That's because it's quiet enough to pump in public when needed and powerful enough to get the job done whether you use it as a single or dual pump.

    Suggested reading:

    • Spectra S2 breast pump review: everything you need to know
    • Which is the best Spectra breast pump?
    • Spectra S1 vs Spectra S2: What's the difference, which is better?
    • One IS better: Spectra S1 vs. Medela Freestyle: Which is better for 2019?
    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Mr. See Jast

    Last Updated: 03/06/2023

    Views: 6010

    Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

    Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Mr. See Jast

    Birthday: 1999-07-30

    Address: 8409 Megan Mountain, New Mathew, MT 44997-8193

    Phone: +5023589614038

    Job: Chief Executive

    Hobby: Leather crafting, Flag Football, Candle making, Flying, Poi, Gunsmithing, Swimming

    Introduction: My name is Mr. See Jast, I am a open, jolly, gorgeous, courageous, inexpensive, friendly, homely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.